Lancaster, SC Independent Insurance Agency

Auto, Home, Motorcycle, & Mobile Home Insurance

Auto Plus Insurance Group LLC is dedicated to providing our customers with friendly service and the best rates. We represent 16 companies so that we can find the best coverage, price, and payment plan for your individual situation.

We opened in October 1999. Our owners, Rhonda McCain and Donna G. Newton have over 29 years of experience in the insurance industry. As our customer, you are important to us–and we’ll treat you that way! We understand that each person has different insurance needs and we’ll work with you to make your experience as easy as possible.

Our Lancaster, SC office offers you the convenience of paying premiums by mail or in person. You’re always welcome to come in and discuss any problems or issues that you have with your insurance. Our professional, courteous staff will take the time to understand your needs and find the best solution for you.

Insurance Products & Services

We currently represent 16 insurance companies, including Travelers, National General (formerly GMAC), and Safeco. We offer the following types of insurance coverage:

  • Auto
  • Home
  • Motorcycle
  • Mobile Home
  • Rental Property
  • Boat
  • Camper
  • Commercial Auto
  • Non-Owners SR22

Low monthly payment plans and quick transactions are available. We also accept cash payments.

Let’s Get in Touch!

Contact Auto Plus Insurance Group LLC for more information on our independent insurance agency in Lancaster, SC. Call today for a phone quote and see how we will shop the best rate for you!

Insurance Company Claims

 America’s Ins Co  1-800-315-6090
 America Reliable  1-800-245-1505
 Assurance America  1-888-223-8409
 Bristol West  1-800-274-7865
 Capitol Preferred  1-888-388-2742
 Cornerstone National  1-888-735-5764
 Everest/Arrowhead General  1-800-545-7742
 Gainsco  1-800-526-8016
 Lyndon Southern  1-855-605-7639
 National Casualty Ins Co  1-800-423-7675
 National General (GMAC)  1-800-468-3466
 Omni  1-800-727-6664
 Peak/Dairyland  1-800-462-6342
 Progressive  1-800-776-4737
 Safeco  1-877-566-6001
 Travelers  1-877-828-4132
 United Auto  1-866-913-6866
 Universal Property & Casualty Ins Co  1-800-425-9113
 Victoria  1-800-888-8424